Friday, January 18, 2008

2008 Edgar Nominees Announced

by Marcus Sakey

This morning Mystery Writers of America announced the 2008 Edgar nominations. The Edgar is the most prestigious annual award in the field, and this year's nominees are terrific. A partial list is below; click here to see the full list.



Christine Falls by Benjamin Black (Henry Holt and Company)
Priest by Ken Bruen (St. Martin's Minotaur)
The Yiddish Policemen's Union by Michael Chabon (HarperCollins)
Soul Patch by Reed Farrel Coleman (Bleak House Books)
Down River by John Hart (St. Martin's Minotaur)


Missing Witness by Gordon Campbell (HarperCollins – William Morrow)
In the Woods by Tana French (Penguin Group – Viking)
Snitch Jacket by Christopher Goffard (The Rookery Press)
Head Games by Craig McDonald (Bleak House Books)
Pyres by Derek Nikitas (St. Martin's Minotaur)


Queenpin by Megan Abbott (Simon & Schuster)
Blood of Paradise by David Corbett (Random House - Mortalis)
Cruel Poetry by Vicki Hendricks (Serpent's Tail)
Robbie's Wife by Russell Hill (Hard Case Crime)
Who is Conrad Hirst? by Kevin Wignall (Simon & Schuster)


"The Catch" – Still Waters by Mark Ammons (Level Best Books)
"Blue Note" – Chicago Blues by Stuart M. Kaminsky (Bleak House Books)
"Hardly Knew Her" – Dead Man's Hand by Laura Lippman (Harcourt Trade Publishers)
"The Golden Gopher" – Los Angeles Noir by Susan Straight (Akashic Books
"Uncle" – A Hell of a Woman” by Daniel Woodrell (Busted Flush Press)


If/Then by David Foley (International Mystery Writers' Festival)
Panic by Joseph Goodrich (International Mystery Writers' Festival)
Books by Stuart M. Kaminsky (International Mystery Writers' Festival)


As always, I've read fewer than I would have expected, which means I've got some work to do in the next months. However, there are a couple I'd like to draw special attention to.

Derek Nikitas, nominated for PYRES, is a fellow member of the Killer Year group (as is Sean Chercover), and I had the privilege to blurb his book, so his nomination gives me a very personal pride. Way to do, Derek!

Ken Bruen is a friend and a mentor and an inspiration, and I love that in the last few years his work has really started to get the acclaim it deserves.

Laura Lippman is a wonderful writer, and the absolute soul of class and grace. While I'm thrilled she was nominated for her story, I'm stunned that WHAT THE DEAD KNOW didn't make the list.

My friend John Hart pulled off an amazing feat; he was nominated last year for the Best First for KING OF LIES. To return with a nomination for Best Novel on his sophomore effort is incredible.

Reed Farrel Coleman is a stone-pro who is long-overdue for this sort of attention. Very happy to see that one.

Stuart Kaminsky was nominated for not one but two Edgars, one of them for his contribution to CHICAGO BLUES, the anthology edited by Libby Hellman that includes stories from the Outfit. His story is terrific, as is the antho.

Speaking of the anthology, Alison Janssen and Ben LeRoy at Bleak House Books deserve special notice--rarely has a publisher not based in New York had such success. Three award noms, including in two Best Novel categories. Go, go, go!

Finally, for the record, this isn't a vote or a critique or anything of the sort. These are folks I know. I'm just giving love to friends.

Congratulations to all the Edgar nominees! It's a hell of a list.


JD Rhoades said...

You and Sean wuz robbed. Laura, too.

Libby said...

Agree wholeheartedly. Both Sean and Marcus deserved to be on the list.

But way to go BLEAK HOUSE (who published Chicago Blues, btw...)!!! 3 Edgar nods.

Marcus Sakey said...

That's sweet of you both to say, and it really means a lot to me. But I've had more than my share of good luck this year. And the nominees, those I've read, are all stellar. I'm psyched for them.

Rob said...

I heard they are adding a catagory for Best Hair. Marcus is a shoe-in for that one. No question.

Steve Z. said...

Another one that could have been on the BEST FIRST NOVEL list is Vinnie's Head by Marc Lecard. I thought it was quite original, imaginative, and very funny. As a reader, I love a book that keeps me turning the pages because I don't know where it's going (instead of the writer trying to build to a climax you can see a mile away). I had no idea where Vinnie's Head (both the head itself and the story) would end up, but the journey was a hell of a lot of fun. Plus I loved the idea of the protagonist being a sap, a sucker, a mark. Not something you see very often, maybe because it's awfully hard to do.

D.A. Davenport said...

Terrific list, but could have been better with Marcus and Sean included!

I also see a lot of additions to the TBR pile soon. Have to catch up on some of the nominees before the awards.

Marcus, I noticed your name on the list for LCC Denver. So I'll get to meet you sooner than Baltimore for that Macallan's. LODO is full of great bars and nightclubs, so I am sure everyone coming will have a marvelous time. Looking forward to March- It's my first convention and I am stoked, to say the least.